• Home
  • Art & Culture
  • Business
  • Food
  • Tourism
  • Contact Us
Tuesday, March 2, 2021
No Result
View All Result
NEWSLETTER
The Martha's Vineyard Guide
  • Home
  • News Agencies
    • The MV Times
    • The MV Gazette
  • Tourist Agencies
    • MVOL
    • MV Chamber
  • Food Agencies
    • Edible Vineyard
    • Farm Field Sea
  • Community PR
  • Submit a Press Release
  • Contact Us
  • Home
  • News Agencies
    • The MV Times
    • The MV Gazette
  • Tourist Agencies
    • MVOL
    • MV Chamber
  • Food Agencies
    • Edible Vineyard
    • Farm Field Sea
  • Community PR
  • Submit a Press Release
  • Contact Us
No Result
View All Result
The Martha's Vineyard Guide
No Result
View All Result
Home News

The Vineyard Gazette – Martha’s Vineyard News

by mvguide
October 2, 2020
in News, Tourism
0
0
SHARES
0
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Developers of the Meetinghouse Place subdivision in Edgartown have appealed the Martha’s Vineyard Commission’s decision to deny the plan, setting up a potential court battle over the commission’s broad powers to regulate developments on the Vineyard.

Utah developers Douglas K. Anderson and Richard G. Matthews want to subdivide 54 acres in the rural perimeters of Edgartown into 29 house lots.

The commission voted to deny the plan in a 10-4 vote in August after an exhaustive two-year review that included multiple redesigns of the plan and numerous public hearings.

Density, environmental impacts and the increasing build-out and suburbanization of the Vineyard were all issues during the hearings and review. Developers redesigned the plan three times and offered to make substantial contributions to affordable housing, among other things.

In the end the commission decided by a large majority that the detriments of the development plan outweighed the benefits.

In the final written decision recorded last week, commission executive director Adam Turner formally spelled out the reasons for the denial.

“The commission finds that although the project satisfied in some form many of the MVC guidelines, it did not provide sufficient benefits to outweigh the overwhelming detriment to the rural, natural character of the area, and the Vineyard as a whole,” it says in part. “In the end . . . the project remained out of character. The houses remained out of scale, and environmental and energy issues were never fully solved.”

In a 30-page appeal filed in Dukes County superior court Wednesday, attorneys for the developers called the decision to deny the project on the grounds of character, among other considerations, “arbitrary and capricious,” arguing at length that the regional planning body did not consider necessary alternatives, overstepped its enabling legislation and denied a project that adhered to nearly all of its conditions.

“The commission’s finding that the project would ‘suburbanize’ the Vineyard, add more ‘luxury’ housing which is allegedly unneeded and would be ‘out of character’ were arbitrary and whimsical, inconsistent, subjective and denied the proposed development on non-uniform standards,” the appeal says in part.

The complaint also claims commissioners “moved the goalposts” on applicants and devised their own “ad hoc” standards of review on issues like house size, conservation land and the number of units allowable on a given site.

“The commission created standards to fit individual commissioners’ agendas,” the complaint says. “Therefore, its decision is void as a matter of law.”

Created by an act of the state legislature in 1974, the commission is a regional planning body charged with preserving the unique natural, historical, ecological, scientific, and cultural values of the Island, as well as promoting sound local economies. Its broad powers include reviewing and regulating what are termed developments of regional impact (DRI).

The Meeting House project was referred to the commission as a mandatory DRI in the spring of 2018 by the Edgartown planning board.

It is the largest subdivision to come before the commission in many years.

The two developers bought the property off Meeting House Way in 2017 for $6.6 million. They are represented in the appeal by Edward T. Dangel, an Edgartown attorney with the firm Dangel & Mattchen.




Source link

mvguide

mvguide

Related Posts

The Vineyard Gazette – Martha’s Vineyard News

The Vineyard Gazette – Martha’s Vineyard News

by mvguide
March 2, 2021
0

When it comes to tall ships, there are few things Capt. Robert S. Douglas — the legendary, 88-year old...

The Vineyard Gazette – Martha’s Vineyard News

The Vineyard Gazette – Martha’s Vineyard News

by mvguide
March 1, 2021
0

After a chaotic Saturday morning that saw widespread confusion when the Martha’s Vineyard Hospital received no new state vaccine...

The Vineyard Gazette – Martha’s Vineyard News

The Vineyard Gazette – Martha’s Vineyard News

by mvguide
February 28, 2021
0

Herb Foster, the perpetually vibrant linguist, library trustee and World War II veteran who trained his beaming smile on...

The Vineyard Gazette – Martha’s Vineyard News

The Vineyard Gazette – Martha’s Vineyard News

by mvguide
February 27, 2021
0

The Martha’s Vineyard Commission’s new energy policy is going back to the drawing board after commissioners raised questions about...

African American History Tour Of Oak Bluffs

African American History Tour Of Oak Bluffs

by mvguide
February 26, 2021
0

Martha’s Vineyard has a rich and diverse history with people of color. During Black History month, we are taking...

The Vineyard Gazette – Martha’s Vineyard News

by mvguide
February 26, 2021
0

The MV Community Seed Library Group has postponed its annual Seed Swap and Giveaway to March 6, from 10...

Next Post
Cape Cod’s Black leaders castigate Trump for refusal to condemn white supremacy – News – capecodtimes.com

Cape Cod's Black leaders castigate Trump for refusal to condemn white supremacy - News - capecodtimes.com

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Facebook Twitter

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Subscribe and receive updates in your email inbox.
SUBSCRIBE

Category

  • Agriculture & Land
  • Art, Culture & Activities
  • Business
  • Food
  • News
  • Tourism
Currently Playing

© 2020 The Martha's Vineyard Guide - Site by Sitka Creations® LLC.

No Result
View All Result
  • Betsy Shands
  • Breakwater MV Real Estate
  • Community PR
  • Contact Us
  • Darcie Lee Hannaway
  • Home
  • JMS Rentals
  • Marston Clough
  • MV Center for Living
  • MV Community Greenhouse
  • MV Mediation Program
  • Nelson Mechanical Design, Inc.
  • Seth Williams Plumbing and Heating
  • Submit a Press Release
  • Summer Shades
  • Trademark Services LLC

© 2020 The Martha's Vineyard Guide - Site by Sitka Creations® LLC.