• Home
  • Art & Culture
  • Business
  • Food
  • Tourism
  • Contact Us
Wednesday, April 21, 2021
No Result
View All Result
NEWSLETTER
The Martha's Vineyard Guide
  • Home
  • News Agencies
    • The MV Times
    • The MV Gazette
  • Tourist Agencies
    • MVOL
    • MV Chamber
  • Food Agencies
    • Edible Vineyard
    • Farm Field Sea
  • Community PR
  • Submit a Press Release
  • Contact Us
  • Home
  • News Agencies
    • The MV Times
    • The MV Gazette
  • Tourist Agencies
    • MVOL
    • MV Chamber
  • Food Agencies
    • Edible Vineyard
    • Farm Field Sea
  • Community PR
  • Submit a Press Release
  • Contact Us
No Result
View All Result
The Martha's Vineyard Guide
No Result
View All Result
Home News

The Vineyard Gazette – Martha’s Vineyard News

by mvguide
March 6, 2021
in News, Tourism
0
The Vineyard Gazette – Martha’s Vineyard News
0
SHARES
0
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

A long-awaited toxicology report became a new point of tension at a Martha’s Vineyard Commission hearing Thursday, as scientists assessed the regional high school’s proposed athletic field renovation for health risks and environmental impact.

The hearing, which drew over 100 participants, marked the third in an ongoing series of public hearings devoted to the $7 million field renovation, which is under review by the commission as a development of regional impact (DRI). The project, which has sown divisions in the community, calls for five natural grass fields and one synthetic turf field, among other facility improvements.

Previous hearings aired testimony from proponents and opponents, passionate on all sides.

On Thursday, commissioners turned their attention to a question at the core of the project’s review — the toxicity of synthetic fields. In a highly technical three-hour discussion, commissioners heard testimony from at least three conflicting toxicology experts brought on by the MVC, the high school and the Field Fund, a primary opnnent of the project.

Ron Myrick from the independent consulting firm Tetra Tech kicked off the conversation with the results of a toxicology report analyzing the chemicals used to make the synthetic turf and their potential risks to human health and the environment.

The tests were ordered by the commission and conducted independently by Tetra Tech, with a peer review and recommendation completed by the firm Horsely Witten. The high school paid for the $51,000 report.

Mr. Myrick said test results showed small amounts of per and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS), which can be harmful to humans but are present in most soils.

“In summary, this is what we found, low level concentrations . . . of . . . semi volatiles, metals and PFAS in the various synthetic turf components,” he said. “However, these materials are present in concentrations that are consistent with background concentrations in natural soil or concentrations well below the risk based standards.”

Brian Massa, a scientist with Horsely Witten, added that chemicals from the field could leach into the Island groundwater, but concluded that drinking water would remain within Massachusetts DEP standards.

Both scientists strongly emphasized the limits of the testing science currently available for PFAS, urging the school to adopt a long-term monitoring plan.

Two more toxicologists — one hired by the high school, the other by project opponents — then gave their own, conflicting testimony regarding the report, engaging in occasionally tense exchanges.

Kristen Mello, the expert hired by the Field Fund, said the turf chemicals posed serious health risks.

“PFAS exposure has been linked to reductions in antibody response and disease resistance, increases in airway hypersensitivity, asthma and risk of autoimmune disease,” she said in part.

Dr. Laura Green, the toxicologist hired by the high school, pushed back vehemently, arguing that PFAS is already present in the environment. She said concerning levels of lead found in Vineyard soil presented a larger problem than PFAS.

“For the life of me I cannot understand why anyone would be concerned about perfluorinated-alkyl substances here. There is a lot more in dirt than there is in BrockFill, but these are tiny numbers,” Dr. Green said. “We toxicologists are concerned much more about heavy metals than we are about [PFAS].”

During a question and answer period that followed, a few commissioners pushed back against testimony from the high school toxicologist. In a sharp exchange, commissioner Ben Robinson asked about how to reconcile increasing levels of chemicals in the environment as industry regulation standards continue to decrease, leading to more disagreement between the high school and Field Fund experts, and testy remarks from Mr. Robinson.

“What we’re talking about is a single product here, but we’re talking about a significant amount of that single product. And if we want to lower the levels of PFAS in the background we should stop adding PFAS into the background,” he said.

Other commissioners, including Doug Sederholm and Jeff Agnoli, expressed caution about the many unknowns regarding chemicals referenced in the reports.

“I think it would be safe to say based on all the science we’ve heard that there’s a lot more to learn . . . and that would be in the years ahead long after the field would be installed,” Mr. Agnoli said.

In broader public testimony during the hearing’s final half-hour, some expressed confusion at the conflicting scientific reports.

“We’ve all heard experts on both sides, I would say you know they make very strong arguments, but they both can’t be right . . . it can’t both be true that the field is toxic or not toxic” said Sam Hall.

Greg Coutinho spoke forcefully, calling plastic a toxic pollutant and urging the high school to invest in its grass fields, while Cynthia Doyle criticized the school for ignoring the environmental consequences of turf.

“The school leadership says the school is in great academic shape. But that is not true, our high school is in trouble. It is avidly pursuing a project that exacerbates climate change plastic pollution and ignores local zoning,” Ms. Doyle said.

On the other side, Louis Paciello spoke emotionally about the project and its lengthy review process in one of the final comments of the evening.

“We’re working with these kids on these fields, we’ve played on them, we coach on them,” he said. “It’s a little frustrating when we have to sit and listen to all this science and it seems at times that people that are in the trenches are kind of getting overlooked.”

The hearing was continued to March 18.




Source link

mvguide

mvguide

Related Posts

The Vineyard Gazette – Martha’s Vineyard News

The Vineyard Gazette – Martha’s Vineyard News

by mvguide
April 21, 2021
0

A Cape Cod state senator has filed legislation seeking to alter the weighted vote structure on the five-member Steamship...

The Vineyard Gazette – Martha’s Vineyard News

The Vineyard Gazette – Martha’s Vineyard News

by mvguide
April 20, 2021
0

The Vineyard high school football team lost a hard-fought game against Old Rochester Saturday while the indoor track team...

The Vineyard Gazette – Martha’s Vineyard News

by mvguide
April 19, 2021
0

Martha’s Vineyard Community Services has announced a job fair April 20 from 10 a.m. to 4 p.m., on the...

The Vineyard Gazette – Martha’s Vineyard News

The Vineyard Gazette – Martha’s Vineyard News

by mvguide
April 18, 2021
0

After months of testimony, the Martha’s Vineyard Commission closed its marathon public hearing Thursday on the regional high school’s...

The Vineyard Gazette – Martha’s Vineyard News

by mvguide
April 17, 2021
0

Saturday from 10 a.m. to noon at beaches around the Island, the Vineyard Conservation Society holds its 29th annual...

Point B Realty Annual B Good To MV Earth Day Beach Cleanup

Point B Realty Annual B Good To MV Earth Day Beach Cleanup

by mvguide
April 17, 2021
0

Each year, the Point B Realty team participates in the Vineyard Conservation’s Earth Day Beach Cleanup. This year, we...

Next Post

The Vineyard Gazette - Martha's Vineyard News

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Facebook Twitter

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Subscribe and receive updates in your email inbox.
SUBSCRIBE

Category

  • Agriculture & Land
  • Art, Culture & Activities
  • Business
  • Food
  • News
  • Tourism
Currently Playing

© 2020 The Martha's Vineyard Guide - Site by Sitka Creations® LLC.

No Result
View All Result
  • Betsy Shands
  • Breakwater MV Real Estate
  • Community PR
  • Contact Us
  • Darcie Lee Hannaway
  • Home
  • JMS Rentals
  • Marston Clough
  • MV Center for Living
  • MV Community Greenhouse
  • MV Mediation Program
  • Nelson Mechanical Design, Inc.
  • Seth Williams Plumbing and Heating
  • Submit a Press Release
  • Summer Shades
  • Trademark Services LLC

© 2020 The Martha's Vineyard Guide - Site by Sitka Creations® LLC.